In short: a good quote for a roof repair names the exact problem, the exact fix, the materials, the area in square or linear feet, the price before taxes, the warranty and the roofer’s RBQ licence number. Get at least three written quotes built on the same scope of work, compare them line by line rather than by total, and be wary of any quote that is far below the others or asks for a large cash deposit.
Asking for quotes for roof repairs sounds simple: call a few roofers, wait for the numbers, pick the lowest. In practice, most homeowners in Montreal and the rest of Quebec end up with three documents that do not describe the same job. One roofer quotes a few shingles, another quotes a full section with new underlayment, a third sends a single line that says “repair roof leak – $1,200”. Comparing them is like comparing three restaurant bills without the menu.
This guide is the complete method for getting roof repair quotes you can actually trust and compare. It covers what to prepare before you call, what a complete quote must contain, how roofers build their prices, how to compare offers side by side, which warning signs should make you walk away, and what to check before you sign. It applies to sloped shingle roofs, metal roofs and flat roofs on duplexes, triplexes and commercial buildings.
Why roof repair quotes vary so much
It is common to receive roof repair quotes that differ by 50% or even 100% for what looks like the same job. That does not automatically mean someone is overcharging. Prices move with several factors that the homeowner rarely sees:
- The diagnosis itself. A leak that shows up in your ceiling can start several feet away from the stain. One roofer may plan to replace a cracked vent boot; another may have found that the flashing along the chimney is the real culprit. Different diagnoses lead to different prices.
- The scope. “Replace damaged shingles” can mean five shingles or a 10 by 10 foot section with new underlayment and ice and water shield. The second job costs several times more, and it may be the right one.
- Access and safety. A steep roof on a three-storey building in the Plateau, a roof with no place to set a ladder, or a job that requires a lift or scaffolding costs more than a low bungalow roof in a suburb.
- Minimum charges. Most companies have a minimum service charge that covers travel, setup and insurance. A five-minute fix still costs that minimum.
- Warranty and overhead. A licensed, insured company that offers a written warranty on its work has costs that an uninsured individual does not, and its prices reflect that.
For typical price ranges by type of repair, including inspections, shingle sections, vent boots, chimney flashing and flat roof patches, see our roof repair price list for Montreal homes. Keep it open while you read your quotes: it gives you a reference point for each line.
Before you ask for quotes: prepare your roof file
The more precise the information you give, the more precise and comparable the quotes you receive. Fifteen minutes of preparation saves days of back-and-forth.
1. Document the problem
- Take dated photos of every symptom: water stains on the ceiling, drips in the attic, missing or curled shingles visible from the ground, granules in the gutters, blistered membrane on a flat roof.
- Note when the problem appears: only during heavy rain, during snowmelt, when wind blows from a certain direction, or all the time. Leaks that appear only during thaw often point to ice dams rather than a hole in the roof.
- If you can safely access the attic, look for wet insulation, dark stains on the roof deck or daylight coming through.
2. Gather the basic facts about your roof
- Type of roof: asphalt shingles, metal, elastomeric membrane, TPO, EPDM, tar and gravel.
- Approximate age of the roof covering and date of the last repair, if you know it.
- Number of storeys and how the roof is accessed.
- Any previous warranty documents from the roofer who installed it. Some repairs may still be covered.
3. Decide what you are asking for
Be clear in your request: do you want a repair of a specific problem, an inspection with a report and a recommendation, or a comparison between repairing and replacing? If your roof is near the end of its life, a repair quote alone may not answer your real question. Our guide on whether to repair or replace a flat roof helps you make that call, and the article on what a roof replacement estimate should include covers the other side of the decision.
How many quotes should you get?
For most roof repairs, three written quotes is the right number. One quote gives you no reference point. Two quotes that disagree leave you with no tie-breaker. Three quotes usually reveal a pattern: two prices in the same range and one outlier, or one diagnosis that differs from the others. Beyond four or five quotes, you mostly spend time without learning anything new. We explain this in more detail in how many roof repair estimates you should get.
The exception is a true emergency. If water is coming into your home during a storm, the priority is a temporary protection such as a tarp or an emergency patch, from the first qualified roofer who can come. You can then take the time to collect proper quotes for the permanent repair. See our article on emergency roof repairs for what counts as an emergency and what it typically costs.
To save time, you can request several quotes at once instead of calling roofers one by one. Our page on getting multiple roof repair quotes fast explains how, and Estimations Pro can put you in touch with up to four roofers in your area with a single free request.
Get up to 4 free roof repair quotes
Describe your roof problem once and receive quotes from roofing contractors in Montreal and surrounding areas. Free, no obligation.
Request my quotesWhat a complete roof repair quote must include
A serious roof repair quote is a written document, not a number sent by text message. Use this list as a checklist. If an item is missing, ask the roofer to add it before you compare.
| Item | What to look for |
|---|---|
| Company identification | Legal business name, address, phone, NEQ and RBQ licence number |
| Diagnosis | What is wrong and where: “cracked rubber boot on plumbing vent, north slope”, “lifted flashing at chimney base” |
| Detailed scope of work | Each task listed: remove, replace, seal, install, clean up |
| Quantities | Square feet of shingles or membrane, linear feet of flashing, number of vents or drains |
| Materials | Brand and product line, type of underlayment, type of sealant or membrane |
| Hidden damage clause | Price per sheet of plywood or per square foot of deck if rot is found once the roof is opened |
| Price | Total before taxes, then GST and QST shown separately |
| Payment terms | Deposit amount, schedule, accepted payment methods |
| Schedule | Estimated start date and duration, weather conditions |
| Warranty | Workmanship warranty in years, in writing, plus manufacturer warranty on materials |
| Cleanup and disposal | Removal of debris, magnet sweep for nails, container if needed |
| Validity | How long the price is valid (often 15 to 30 days) |
On a flat roof, also look for details on the membrane system (elastomeric, TPO or EPDM), the treatment of drains and parapets, and how the new section will be joined to the existing membrane. Our comparison of elastomeric, TPO and EPDM membranes will help you understand what you are being offered.
How roofers build the price of a repair
Understanding the structure of a price helps you ask the right questions instead of simply asking for a discount. Most roof repair quotes combine five components:
- Minimum charge or mobilization. Travel, loading, ladders or lift, safety equipment and setup. Often between $150 and $400 for a simple call in Greater Montreal, sometimes credited against the repair.
- Labour. Usually the largest part. It depends on the time on the roof, the size of the crew and the difficulty of access. Steep or high roofs require more safety measures and slower work.
- Materials. Shingles, underlayment, ice and water shield, flashing, sealants, membrane, vents. On small repairs, materials are often a small share of the total.
- Disposal. Removal of old materials and, for larger repairs, a container rental.
- Overhead and margin. Insurance, licence, vehicles, administration, warranty reserve and profit. A legitimate company must cover these costs to stay in business and honour its warranty.
This is why a very small repair can seem expensive: the fixed costs are spread over a short job. If you have several small problems, ask for them to be quoted together. Grouping work into one visit is one of the most effective ways to lower the cost per repair. For a deeper look at what drives roofing prices, read why roofers are so expensive.
How to compare roof repair quotes line by line
Once you have three written quotes, resist the urge to look at the totals first. Follow these steps instead.
Step 1: Check that the diagnoses agree
Put the three diagnoses side by side. If all three roofers identify the same cause, you can be fairly confident about the problem. If one of them sees something the others missed, call that roofer and ask them to explain, ideally with photos. Then ask the other two whether they checked that area. A good roofer will not be offended by the question.
Step 2: Normalize the scope
Make a simple table with one row per task and one column per roofer. Mark which tasks each quote includes. You will often find that the cheapest quote leaves out underlayment, flashing replacement, cleanup or the treatment of hidden damage. Ask the roofers whose quotes are incomplete to price the missing items, so that all three quotes cover the same work.
Step 3: Compare quantities and unit prices
If one quote says 80 square feet and another says 200 square feet for the same damaged area, one of them has measured differently or plans a larger repair. Ask why. Then compare unit prices, such as price per square foot of shingles or per linear foot of flashing, rather than totals alone.
Step 4: Compare materials and warranty
A quote that uses a basic three-tab shingle without new underlayment, with a one-year workmanship warranty, is not equivalent to one that uses architectural shingles, new ice and water shield and a five-year warranty. The second one may be worth the higher price. Put the warranty length and what it covers in your comparison table.
Step 5: Look at the total cost, including risk
Only now compare totals, taxes included. Add the possible cost of hidden damage using the unit price each roofer gave you. A quote that looks cheaper can become the most expensive one if its price for rotten decking is high and the roof is old.
Example: three quotes for the same leak
A homeowner in Rosemont has a leak near the chimney of a 20-year-old shingle roof. Quote A: $450, “reseal chimney with caulking”, 1-year warranty. Quote B: $950, “remove shingles around chimney, replace step and counter flashing, new ice and water shield, reinstall shingles”, 5-year warranty. Quote C: $2,400, “replace the entire slope”. Quote A treats the symptom and is likely to fail again within a season or two. Quote C may be justified if the slope is at the end of its life, which the homeowner should ask about. Quote B addresses the cause with a solid warranty and is, in most cases, the best value.
We describe a general comparison method in our French guide on comparing contractor quotes in 7 steps, which also applies to roofing.
Red flags in a roof repair quote
Some warning signs should make you slow down or walk away entirely:
- No RBQ licence number on the quote, or a number that does not match the company name.
- A price far below the others without a clear explanation. It often means missing work, low-quality materials, no insurance or a plan to add extras once the job has started.
- A large cash deposit requested before any material is delivered, or a request to pay everything upfront.
- Pressure to sign immediately: “this price is only valid today”, “we have a crew in your area this afternoon”.
- Unsolicited visits after a storm by someone who “noticed damage” on your roof from the street.
- A vague one-line quote, such as “fix leak”, with no diagnosis, no quantities and no materials.
- No written warranty, or a warranty that is only verbal.
- No taxes on the quote, or an offer of a lower price “without invoice”.
- A diagnosis you cannot verify: refusal to show photos of the damage or to let you see the problem.
Our article on red flags when hiring a roofer lists 14 warning signs in detail, and roofer scams and how to protect yourself covers the most common schemes seen in Quebec.
Check the roofer before you accept a quote
The best quote is worthless if the company cannot or will not stand behind it. Before you sign, take a few minutes to verify:
- The RBQ licence. In Quebec, a contractor who does roofing work for others must hold a licence from the Régie du bâtiment du Québec with the right subcategory. You can check the licence, its status and its subcategories in the Régie du bâtiment du Québec licence holder register.
- Liability insurance. Ask for a certificate of insurance. Work at height carries real risks, and you do not want an accident on your property to become your problem.
- References and recent work. Ask for two or three recent clients with similar repairs, ideally in your area, and look at reviews that describe the work in detail. Our guide on what to look for in roof repair reviews explains how to tell useful reviews from noise.
- Consumer protection. If the contract is signed at your home after an unsolicited visit, special rules for itinerant merchants may apply, including a cancellation period. The Office de la protection du consommateur explains your rights.
For a step-by-step method, read how to verify a roofer’s licence and references and what licence and insurance a roofer needs in Quebec.
Questions to ask each roofer about the quote
A short call after receiving each quote often clarifies more than another visit. Ask what exactly causes the problem and how it was confirmed, whether you can see photos of the damage, whether the repair will last or is a temporary fix, how much life the rest of the roof has, what happens if rotten decking is found, who will do the work, and what the written warranty covers. Our full list is in questions to ask before hiring a roofer.
Paying for the repair
For small repairs, payment is usually made in full when the work is done. For larger repairs, a reasonable deposit to cover materials is common, with the balance on completion and after your inspection of the work. Avoid paying in cash without a receipt, and keep all documents: the quote, the contract, the invoice, the warranty and before-and-after photos. To discuss price without cutting corners, group several small repairs into one visit and stay flexible on timing; our guide on how to negotiate roofing costs explains more.
If the repair is large, compare payment options in our article on roof repair financing options in Quebec. Some roof-related work may also be linked to energy efficiency or other programs; our guide on the roof repair tax deduction in Quebec explains what really qualifies and what does not.
Repair quote or replacement quote?
Sometimes the most useful quote is the one that tells you not to repair. If your roof is near the end of its expected life, has several leaks, or shows widespread wear such as curled shingles, missing granules or a blistered membrane, a series of repairs can cost more over a few years than a replacement. Ask at least one roofer to give you both options: the price of the repair and an estimate for replacement, with their honest opinion on which makes more sense.
For reference, see our guides on the average cost to replace a roof in Montreal, the cost of a new roof in Canada and roofing material costs compared. If you have a flat roof, how long a flat roof lasts will help you judge whether a repair is still worth it.
Compare roof repair quotes the easy way
One free request, up to four roofing contractors in your area. You choose, with no obligation.
Get my free quotesFrequently asked questions
Are roof repair quotes free?
Most roofers in Quebec provide free quotes for standard repairs when they can see the problem from the ground, from a ladder or from photos. A detailed inspection with a written report, or a visit that requires special equipment, may be charged. Ask before the visit, and ask whether the fee is credited if you hire the company.
Can a roofer give me a quote from photos only?
Photos are useful for a first estimate, especially for simple items such as a missing shingle or a damaged vent. For leaks, a visit is usually needed, because the source of the water is often not where the stain appears. Treat a quote based only on photos as preliminary.
What if the roofer finds more damage during the repair?
This is common on older roofs. A good quote includes a unit price for additional work, such as replacing a sheet of plywood. If the quote does not, ask the roofer to stop, show you the damage and give you a written price before continuing.
Is the lowest quote always a bad sign?
No. Sometimes a roofer has lower costs, a crew nearby or a slow week. A low quote becomes a red flag when it is far below the others without a clear reason, when it leaves out tasks the others include, or when it comes with a short or verbal warranty.
Prices in this guide are indicative ranges observed in Greater Montreal in 2026, before GST and QST. They are not official rates and do not replace a written quote based on an inspection of your roof. Licensing and consumer protection rules are summarized for general information; refer to the Régie du bâtiment du Québec and the Office de la protection du consommateur for the official rules.